In what may have been the funniest skit from this weekend’s episode of Saturday Night Live, host Matt Damon and cast member Leslie Jones play huge Weezer fans who can’t seem to agree on anything.

Damon’s character loves everything the band has done, including this year’s Pacific Daydream, while Jones is a ‘purist,’ who claims the band hasn’t released anything good since Pinkerton.

Weezer will release The Black Album in 2019.

[Saturday Night Live via YouTube]